Dear Editor and Dr. Richard Togman,
As a former business owner and resident of Thunder Bay, I recognize the pivotal role that community support plays in the success of our public library system. The proposal to build a new branch, the Central Library, within a portion of the Intercity Shopping Centre is undoubtedly well-intentioned and reflects a commitment to fostering knowledge and community engagement.
However, I would like to express my concerns regarding the potential impact of this development on the future of the Intercity Shopping Centre.
The concept of “dead malls” is a phenomenon that has been widely documented and studied. Malls across North America have struggled to retain their original allure and purpose, facing declines in foot traffic and tenant occupancy. The development of non-retail spaces, such as libraries, within these shopping centres can signal the beginning of a downward trend.
In many cases, the introduction of such facilities can be seen as an attempt to repurpose declining retail space rather than revitalizing it through robust private sector investment and retail development.
As someone who values both the library and the shopping centre, I believe there is a better solution that supports the interests of both entities.
The vacant land at 923 Fort William Road presents an excellent opportunity for the development of a new library branch. This location would allow the library to establish a critical community hub in the Central district of the city, without compromising the retail focus and potential resurgence of the Intercity Shopping Centre.
It is essential to learn from past experiences and avoid repeating history. The County Fair Shopping Centre saw a dilution of its retail appeal with the integration of a library, which did not bode well for its future. We have the chance to resurrect the Intercity Shopping Centre as a vibrant retail destination, but this vision requires a focus on enhancing private sector retail development, in line with the centre's original intent.
This is not about being fearful of change - it is about making thoughtful and strategic decisions that ensure the long-term viability of both our library system and our shopping centres. By situating the new Central Library on the vacant land at 923 Fort William Road, we can achieve a win-win scenario that benefits the entire community.
Thank you for considering this perspective. I hope that together, we can find a solution that honours the legacy of both the Thunder Bay Public Library and the Intercity Shopping Centre.
Sincerely,
Justin Frape
